How we measured it
The questions are the 40 fixed English buyer questions of our AI Source Index: 16 "best X" questions, 8 "alternatives to X", 8 head-to-head comparisons and 8 "how do I choose" questions. Every week they go to six AI assistants through their APIs: Perplexity, ChatGPT (OpenAI's API with web search; gpt-4o-mini to 19 October 2026, gpt-5-mini from 26 October to 9 November), Gemini, Claude, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. The original study used every run published by then: 3, 7, 14, 21 and 28 September and 5 October 2026; the update below adds the runs of 12, 19 and 26 October and 2 and 9 November. Each assistant is asked each question once per run.
- Unit: one domain in one answer. A domain is the lowercase host with a leading www. removed, counted once per answer however many of its pages were cited. Google's own shopping links are dropped, as the public index drops them.
- Retained: cited again for the same question by the same AI assistant in the next run.
- Failed checks are left out, not counted as losses. 29 of Claude's 40 checks failed on 14 September and one AI Overviews check failed on 5 October; those question-assistant pairs leave every comparison that touches those runs. An answer that came back with no source at all stays in: if a domain was cited one week and the next answer cited nothing, it counts as gone.
- Every rate is a count out of a count with a 95% Wilson interval. The same domains recur within a question, so those intervals are slightly too narrow; resampling whole questions gives 46.2–49.8% for the headline rate instead of 46.8–49.2%.
The rows behind every number are public in the AI Source Index, one line per question, AI assistant and run, and we are publishing the analysis script beside them. How the index collects its answers is on the methodology page.
Eleven weeks on: the update of 13 November 2026
This guide first covered six runs, to 5 October. The index has asked the same 40 questions five more times since, to 9 November, so we ran the same two scripts, unchanged except for the list of weeks, over all eleven runs. The sections after this one are the original six-run study and keep its numbers.
- Cited again the next week: 6,330 of 13,864 domains, 45.7% (resampling whole questions: 44.2–47.1%). Six runs had given 48.0%. The ten single pairs ranged from 38.3% (19 to 26 October) to 55.2% (3 to 7 September).
- The same page: 39.1% of cited URLs were cited again the next week (6,014 of 15,397). When a domain stayed, at least one of the same pages came with it 90.2% of the time (5,707 of 6,330).
- First-time citations: 24.9% were back the next week (900 of 3,617), and 3.0% held for four weeks in a row (79 of 2,642). But a citation that holds gets stickier: after two runs in a row it made a third 40.4% of the time (324 of 802), after three 49.7% (146 of 294), after four 58.5% (79 of 135).
- Dropouts: 22.3% of the domains that dropped out between two runs were back the very next run (1,487 of 6,683), and 44.5% came back at some later run of the period (3,015 of 6,772).
After about seven weeks, a quarter of the sources stay
| Runs later | Cited again | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6,330 of 13,864 | 45.7% |
| 2 | 4,896 of 12,459 | 39.3% |
| 4 | 3,346 of 10,005 | 33.4% |
| 6 | 2,015 of 7,066 | 28.5% |
| 8 | 1,061 of 4,050 | 26.2% |
| 10 | 363 of 1,416 | 25.6% |
Six runs could not say how long the pool of sources itself lasts. Eleven runs give a first answer: the loss is steep at first and then slows, and from about seven runs on it stays near a quarter. Of the 1,220 domains cited on 3 September for questions answered in every run since, 296 (24.3%) were cited again for the same question on 9 November, ten weeks later, but only 42 (3.4%) had been cited in every run in between. Every question has a small core of sources the AI assistant keeps returning to, and a larger fringe that changes from week to week.
The big sources are still the stickiest. The 20 domains cited most on 3 September were cited again a week later 59.0% of the time in the later pairs (1,276 of 2,163), against 41.5% for all other domains (4,272 of 10,285).
A new model changed almost every source
On 21 October we moved the index's ChatGPT from gpt-4o-mini to gpt-5-mini, OpenAI's newer model. In the next pair, 19 to 26 October, ChatGPT cited 15 of the 255 domains it had cited a week before for the same questions again: 5.9%. In its nine other pairs it kept between 27.7% and 57.1%. In the same pair, Claude kept 55.9% and Perplexity 52.7%, so the week itself was not unusual.
Leaving that pair out, ChatGPT kept 1,025 of 2,232 domains, 45.9%, about the same as the panel as a whole. The two runs since the switch were lower than before it (27.7% and 36.7%), but two runs are too few to say whether the newer model simply changes its sources more often. OpenAI is retiring gpt-5-mini, so on 11 November the index's ChatGPT moved to a newer model again; the runs after that will show whether the second switch moves the sources as much as the first.
The lesson for anyone tracking AI answers is practical: when an AI assistant changes its model, an answer can change its sources almost completely in a single week. That is not your page getting worse. It is a new baseline, and the weeks after the change tell you more than the weeks before it.
AI assistants over ten week pairs
| AI assistant | Cited again | Share | Interval |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | 1,418 of 2,639 | 53.7% | 48.9–58.5% |
| Perplexity | 938 of 1,818 | 51.6% | 48.2–54.8% |
| Gemini | 1,868 of 4,100 | 45.6% | 42.5–48.6% |
| ChatGPT | 1,040 of 2,487 | 41.8% | 39.0–44.7% |
| Google AI Overviews | 741 of 1,932 | 38.4% | 35.3–41.4% |
| Google AI Mode | 325 of 888 | 36.6% | 30.5–42.0% |
The order is the same as in six runs at the top and the bottom: Claude and Perplexity keep the most, Google's two surfaces the fewest. ChatGPT's place depends on the model switch above. A single week pair still reorders the middle.
What could make the eleven-week numbers wrong
- From 15 to 28 October our data provider returned Google AI Overviews' and AI Mode's source lists cut to about three domains, which touches the pairs from 12 October to 2 November. Leaving out the four pairs those runs are in, the panel kept 3,967 of 8,341 domains, 47.6%.
- Between 3 September and 9 November the index's instrument version changed three times, and the collector that reads the AI assistants' answers was revised three times (for the runs of 5 October, 2 November and 9 November). Over the seven pairs with the same instrument on both sides, 46.8% were cited again (4,533 of 9,685), close to the 45.7% of all ten.
- Still one sample per AI assistant per question per week, through the assistants' APIs and our data provider, in English, for the US. The ten-week figure rests on one pair of runs (3 September and 9 November).
The original study: six runs, 3 September to 5 October 2026
Everything below is the first version of this guide, with its numbers as published on 7 October.
About half of cited domains are back the next week
Pooled over the five week-to-week pairs, 3,335 of the 6,947 domains an AI assistant cited for a question were cited again for the same question by the same assistant one run later: 48.0%. The individual pairs ranged from 42.4% (28 September to 5 October, 625 of 1,474) to 55.2% (3 to 7 September, 782 of 1,416). That highest pair is also the only one four days apart instead of seven.
Pages turn over slightly faster than domains. The same URL was cited again the next week 41.4% of the time (3,201 of 7,739). But when a domain stayed, at least one of the same pages came with it in 90.9% of cases (3,032 of 3,335). Week to week, what changes is mostly which sites an answer draws on, not which page of a site it keeps.
Most new citations are gone a week later, and old ones flicker
Follow the citations that appeared for the first time in one of the runs, and most are gone a week later:
- Back the next week: 533 of 1,950, 27.3%.
- Present in each of the next two weeks: 193 of 1,497, 12.9%.
- Each of the next three: 69 of 1,058, 6.5%.
- Each of the next four: 26 of 568, 4.6%.
Survival in an unbroken run understates how many sources come back, though. Of the domains cited on 3 September, only 11.0% were cited in every one of the next five runs (139 of 1,259), yet 36.4% were cited again on 5 October (458 of 1,259). Many of them were missing for a week or two in between.
Over all six runs, half of the distinct combinations of question, AI assistant and domain appeared in only one run: 1,781 of 3,592, 49.6%. Only 139 (3.9%) appeared in all six. The stable ones are counted again every week they appear, so the one-run citations make up a smaller share of everything an assistant cited: 1,781 of 7,644 citations, 23.3%.
Staying power builds. A first-time citation made the next week 27.3% of the time; one that had already held for two runs in a row made a third 44.5% of the time (193 of 434), and after three in a row, 47.3% (69 of 146).
Decay or noise? Mostly reshuffling, with some drift
Each AI assistant answers each question once a week, and these assistants do not give the same answer every time they are asked. So a domain missing this week may be the assistant's own randomness rather than a decision that the page no longer deserves a citation. We do not ask twice within a week, so we cannot measure that noise directly. Two things in the data point to it.
- Dropped domains come back. Of the domains that dropped out between two runs, 25.3% were back in the very next run (682 of 2,697) and 39.6% were cited again in some later run of the period (1,092 of 2,761).
- The loss does not keep growing at the same pace. 48.0% of domains were cited again one run later, 42.5% two runs later, 42.7% three, 37.5% four and 37.4% five (530 of 1,416, 3 September to 5 October). If each week's answers were random draws from a fixed set of sources, that curve would be flat; it falls about 10 points after the first step, so some sources really do fade. But most of the turnover happens in the first week and does not compound.
The honest reading: a large part of week-to-week churn is the AI assistants reshuffling a pool of sources they keep returning to, and a smaller part is genuine decay. Six runs cannot say how long the pool itself lasts beyond five weeks.
AI assistants differ, but one week cannot rank them
Pooled over all five pairs, Claude and Perplexity kept the most of their sources and Google AI Mode the fewest:
- Claude: 563 of 1,033, 54.5% (fewer questions, because of the 14 September failures).
- Perplexity: 537 of 1,000, 53.7%.
- ChatGPT: 611 of 1,300, 47.0%.
- Gemini: 937 of 2,029, 46.2%.
- Google AI Overviews: 502 of 1,123, 44.7%.
- Google AI Mode: 185 of 462, 40.0%.
Resampling whole questions, the intervals for Claude (48.0–60.7%) and Perplexity (50.6–56.4%) do not overlap AI Mode's (32.9–46.9%). ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Overviews cannot be told apart from each other. And no single week pair gives this order. Perplexity kept 65.3% of its sources from 3 to 7 September and 33.2% from 21 to 28 September; AI Overviews went from 59.9% to 26.6% over the same two pairs.
We made that mistake ourselves. On 5 October we quoted one week pair in public, 28 September to 5 October, in which Gemini looked the most stable AI assistant at 53% and the overall figure was 44%. Pooled over five pairs, Gemini is fourth. That count was taken from our database, where Google's own shopping links still count as a domain, and it skipped questions where either answer cited nothing. On the public rows and the rules in this guide, the same pair is 41.4%.
Part of AI Mode's low number is not switching sources at all. In each run, 10 to 16 of its 40 answers cited no source outside Google itself. Counting only pairs where both answers cited something, AI Mode kept 49.1% of its domains (185 of 377).
The biggest sources are the stickiest
youtube.com and reddit.com were the two most cited domains in all six runs, and 7 to 9 of each week's ten most cited domains were still in the top ten the next week. The domains that were already big held on better: the 20 most cited domains of 3 September were retained 60.0% of the time in the later week pairs (604 of 1,007), against 43.1% for every other domain (1,949 of 4,524).
For a smaller site, a single citation is weak evidence of anything. A citation that has held for three or four consecutive weeks is a different thing from one that showed up once.
How this compares with Profound's and Writesonic's citation decay
These answer a different question from ours. They follow a page's share of all citations as it rises and falls, day by day, across whatever questions they track. We ask whether the same AI assistant cites the same domain for the same fixed question a week later. Both find most citations changing within a few weeks: Profound's median page halves its share 11 days after its peak, and in our panel about half of the cited domains were not cited again the following week. Their samples are far larger than our 40 questions, and our weekly runs cannot see a page that rises and fades inside one week. What this study adds is a fixed question set, an interval on every rate, and rows anyone can recount.
Daily or weekly checks
The 11-day half-life is sometimes read as a case for checking every question every day. The two measurements point to a narrower answer. If about half of a question's cited domains change from one week to the next, one check is a snapshot, and what you want is a rate over several checks. A weekly check gives you that rate for every question you track. A daily check adds two things a weekly one cannot see: a page that rises and fades inside the same week, and the day a change happened.
So the split we would make is by question, not by tool. Check daily the handful of questions you are actively working on, where you want to see what happened in the days after you changed a page. Check the rest weekly, and spend what a daily check would cost on more questions instead: a weekly reading across many questions says more about where you stand than a daily one across a few.
What to do with this
- Do not react to one week. A domain that dropped out came back the following week about a fifth of the time over eleven runs (22.3%), and at some later week almost half the time (44.5%).
- Judge a citation by how long it has held. Over eleven runs, one that had held for two runs in a row made a third 40.4% of the time; a first appearance made a second only 24.9% of the time.
- Compare AI assistants over several weeks, never on a single pair of runs. The order changed from one week pair to the next.
- When an AI assistant changes its model, start a new baseline. ChatGPT kept 5.9% of its sources in the week it moved to a newer model.
- Track the domain first. When the domain stayed in an answer, the same page came with it nine times in ten.
- When a Google AI Mode citation disappears, check whether the new answer cited anything at all before concluding a competing page replaced yours.
For which kinds of sites the AI assistants cite in the first place, see what AI assistants actually cite. For how Google's AI answers relate to its own first page, see Google's AI cites pages Google doesn't rank. For whether the six assistants cite the same sources for the same question, see do AI assistants cite the same sources?
Frequently asked questions
How long does an AI citation last?
In our panel of 40 questions on six AI assistants, over eleven weekly runs from 3 September to 9 November 2026, 45.7% of cited domains were cited again for the same question a week later. A domain cited for the first time came back the next week 24.9% of the time. The loss slows down after the first weeks: ten weeks later, 25.6% of the domains cited on 3 September were cited again for the same question.
My site dropped out of an AI answer this week. Is it gone?
Not necessarily. Of the domains that dropped out between two weekly runs, 22.3% were back the very next week and 44.5% returned at some later run within our ten-week window. Look at several weeks before treating a drop as a loss, and check whether the AI assistant changed its model that week.
Which AI assistant keeps its sources longest?
Pooled over ten week pairs, Claude (53.7%) and Perplexity (51.6%) kept the most and Google AI Mode the fewest (36.6%). ChatGPT's 41.8% includes the week it moved to a newer model, when it kept 5.9%; without that pair it kept 45.9%. The order changes from one week pair to the next, so a single week cannot rank the AI assistants.
Can I check these numbers?
Yes. Every question, AI assistant, run and cited URL behind them is public in the AI Source Index, and the rows used here, the script that computes each figure and the independent cross-check are published together under CC BY 4.0, for the six-run study and for the eleven-run update (each linked from its statistic above).